Thursday, January 3, 2008

The Democratic Debates and Loving Arthur Silber

I did something new today, I ran from where I was toward the t.v, rather than away from it.
Today there were Democratic presidential candidates participating in "live televised debates"
I cannot consider myself a Democrat, and hold myself responsible by my own values. And as far as the value of the debates, if honesty were a commodity, I couldn't say much at all. Still, I wanted to see what would happen within the party, especially what they would say regarding U.S involvement in Iran, Healthcare, "national security" etc. Also, I was interested in what would happen when Hillary Clinton was asked to respond to prompted questions. I was hoping that Clinton would be called out for being what I would consider a non-democrat. Even outside of inconsistencies between Clinton and the party, there are clear issues, for example, directly misleading voters, being inconsistent in stance and logic, supporting very strongly the status quo. Clinton talked about structuring our military forces in Iraq to be prepared for conflict with Iran, she also said we would not leave Iraq totally, and that there would always be representative forces, but more immediately the U.S would fight Al-Qaeda in Iraq. Within a relatively basic discussion (lots of sound bytes etc) there was what I wanted to see, candidates challenging Clinton. I thought they did a good job of crushing her planned policies, using the weight of logic, which is something I needed to see.


Now, for the example of why I love Arthur Silber... He did a brilliant job, as is his custom, of illustrating key issues. He describes more astutely, and generally better, the types of things I noticed and took notes on, and ones I hadn't thought of , and wish I had. (maybe I'll copy the notes here later)

He is probably the most consistent of the people whose works I read, in maintaining my respect and interest. If his topics happen to stray from what I was looking for originally, I have not found myself leaving the topic it goes into, as they all seem very valuable.


Go here
http://powerofnarrative.blogspot.com/2007/10/break-goddamned-rules.html
now you're looking at the link.. but you really should be looking at what he wrote about it.

John McCain, U.S integrity, and terror

I watched one of John McCain's campaign speeches recently..
If I could claim to agree with John McCain, it would be on torture,
when he answered the question "what does it mean to you to lead by integrity"

his response "announce we will never torture another person in American custody."

now, that is the part I agree with him on, in all cases I think torture is wrong. (including excessive use of force by police authorities nationwide, but that is a whole other issue)

In promoting our wars in the middle east, and all those great 'American values' they supposedly protect, I see a problem when we are defining people as terrorist threats..

not limited to McCain's question of treatment, there is also slight issue, how do they get into American custody in the first place?

He'd gone on to say we should "close Guantanamo bay, and move them to Ft. Levin where there is a federal detention center."

As far as I'm concerned almost none of the people in custody in the interest of U.S national security are there based on any sort of hard evidence, and shouldn't be detained Anywhere. These arrests and methods of obtaining evidence were well outlined in the Patriot Act, especially SEC. 236A. (a) (for more specifics on what they are defining http://www.state.gov/s/ct/rls/fs/37191.htm) but the patriot act is made up of definitions and actions to be taken against perceived threats be they realistic or not.
It is because of irrational fear and reckless acts on the part of our government that these people are being so mistreated. It is no small group either, in Fran Townsend's statements to Wolf Blitzer on CNN, the number of people we have detained and "rendered" and who we are "not torturing" currently is about a hundred to a hundred-fifty. That is the total that has been disclosed to us, I could see, judging by this administration's willingness to tell the whole truth, there being many more cases of rendition and torture.. (for more estimates on number of detainees and explanation http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/4088746.stm)

What I see here is a failure to address our motivation, method, and moral standing when we arrest these individuals. I don't think we are right to do so in the first place. He says we should continue our policies which are only possible without habeas corpus. I think not having habeas corpus is a pretty important issue in trust and integrity, which should have been better addressed by McCain since "one of the first challenges in '09 is to ensure trust." He didn't address it because he is largely responsible. He initially refused to back legislation that went directly against the Geneva Conventions, but allowed it to instead by determined by the president how to interpret those policies. It was the same kind of move he pulled when dodging questions about his standpoints on topics like gay marriage, saying he'd leave that to the states and other people to decide. Specifically, and better worded

"When the parties emerged, the compromise looked uncannily like the original administration bill. Nominally, we reaffirm the Geneva protections. But the bill explicitly authorizes the president to define what that means. A detainee's right to challenge his detention to an independent judge (habeas corpus) is still eliminated, as is the right of the accused to see evidence. And the CIA retains the ability to spirit people to third countries that don't even pretend to ban torture." http://www.commondreams.org/views06/1001-23.htm

I do not trust a government that arbitrarily detains people for unstated purpose, as long as they should choose to. There are a lot of people working to promote national security, like the JTTF here's a url that has the glittering outlook on their efforts http://www.fbi.gov/page2/dec04/jttf120114.htm.

"And here's the final—and most important—thing you should know about these JTTFs: They are working 24/7/365 to protect you, your families, and your communities from terrorist attack."

I personally am not afraid of terrorist attacks, not nearly as much as I am afraid of losing (and having lost) my individual freedoms here "at home." I cannot stand to think of the amount of human suffering that has been a direct effect of our national security efforts.

We need to wake up, we condemn other countries for Human Rights Violations, when we are a perpetrator of many crimes against our citizens and others. It is the role of the "moral majority" to take action to stop this. Are we so arrogant to believe we can justify these actions by later explaining some benevolent motivation?

Nothing can justify for me this wrongdoing, and the many others committed by our government, and I find myself accountable as a part of this greater and increasingly faceless evil that is the united states. Get me wrong, if that be the case.

babble from oct 26

I watched the news today,
and after leaving the news for C-span

I found myself watching billy crystal giving a performance about hillary clinton, as it is her birthday today. I really do not like her, and people supporting her makes me more unhappy, then that C-Span would broadcast this... no.

No source can be taken directly, including my own interpretations, so I'm going to try to post some of my observations with and without commentary. It is to help me see where I am focusing, and whether or not that is a good idea.

Also, I am reading Walden
and there are many parts which remind me of when I was younger, and spent my time with sheep and chickens and apple trees, and knew where the shadows of the leaves would fall at any time of day and could describe more intimately the plants and rocks that surrounded my then more ridiculous house. I used to imagine what it would be like to be the object I was looking at, its ability to carry something, make food, reflect the sunshine..

These will be increasingly spontaneous, and well, bloggish in that they are more for my personal use than to show some sort of persuasive argument.

Building the U.S Middle Class

I was surveying the home in which I reside today and looking out onto my neighborhood, and a few of my more frequent thoughts resurfaced.

How many hours of labor would it take for each individual in my family, and the families of my neighbors to make the things they own and purchase? Even when recognizing that the machine industry makes some of this easier, I see a huge discrepancy between our lifestyles and the amount of real labor we do. The thousands of hours it likely took to make the materials needed to build the house, make the material goods within it, pave the road, extract the metals and organics from the earth needed even to begin the process. The food grown to feed the people making it, the fuels in the manufacturing process, to ship the materials, and then on top of that to heat the house itself. It probably took thousands of people to create the contents of a few rooms, let alone the whole neighborhood, or state or country. How do I think this is possible, that our possessions exceed our productivity?

I think the answer lies in our role as a global empire. Exploiting whatever energies, laborers and materials we can. Throughout the world are developing nations whose exports we buy at low prices, and whose cheap labor we exploit. (more on this later) This habit of taking from the impoverished is true in our country as well, looking at the labor force, and poverty rates. I see our consumerism, and it is something that in a lot of ways disgusts me. Now, I am not exempt from wrongdoing, as my lifestyle is one that is more in line than not with the majority of the American public. (The idea of the U.S as an empire was also discussed briefly on democracy papers look there for especially worthwhile commentary from a person known to me as Professor Doctor Silas..) I would like for a reference that you look at this map showing percent of U.S population in poverty, there are many factors in this, but I think it is a good visual representation. http://www.raconline.org/maps/mapfiles/poverty.jpg

I look in particular at mass produced goods like clothing, and see where the manufacturing takes place. At the rates we pay, it is a guarantee that the money made by workers is insufficient to survive and support basic human needs. For now I will ignore the environmental complications involved in mass manufacturing. This consumer greed is personally disappointing, because in many ways it is not on purpose. When people buy these things, they are often considering their personal wellbeing, and the wellbeing of their families, and trying to save money. But in doing so they are condemning the people who make these things to compete with one another until the prices are even lower. We often hear of things like nike sweat shops where children and whole communities are forced to work under terrible conditions, there might be a slight uprising in the consumers, like they will switch to another manufacturer, but I do not see people divorcing the system altogether.

I think maybe we should. Within our own country, we should be looking at the wellbeing of all citizens, and only supporting companies which provide a the makings of a good lifestyle (to be defined by the citizens, not me personally) to the people they do business with and employ, if we support large companies at all. If a company is not doing well by its community, there should be some sort of responsibility check, to ensure that the company is not parasitic. Some large companies already have sustained efforts to improve their communities, by supporting schools and other non-profits, and some of these are merely pulling PR stunts to cover up larger issues, and long term damage. There needs to be some sort of regulation on profiteering in masse.

In companies who have the majority of their manufacturing done overseas, I attribute the public apathy to a few key things,
1) the welcoming of low cost no matter how it is achieved (examples could be seen in part of wal-mart the high cost of low prices)
2) Lack of awareness, do they know where their products were made, and who benefits most
3) the belief that outside this country there live a lesser people. (Immortal Technique put it rather well in "the poverty of philosophy")

these of course are largely dependent on greed, and our societies' tendency toward serving their own interests.


The conclusion I've reached so far, is that if possible, I will reduce my participation in this exploitation now and in the near future. I already avoid purchasing fresh clothes, and choose instead to buy clothing that was rejected by consumers or otherwise sent to goodwill. I do not like owning excessive things, and so do not purchase non-food goods very frequently. I hope to find a way to directly encourage companies that meet my goals for the global and local community regarding the wellbeing of workers.
With this I still have much more research and other considerations to think about, but it is something I want to know more and thought people could contribute to.

Legality, Marijuana & other substances

One less common principle I find myself abiding by, is the idea that if a law or policy is not in the best interest of the people it governs, I make no point of following it, as an example I will focus today on enforcement of drug policies.

My non participation in abiding by these laws is not meant to get attention towards the changing of the policies, as would the case with civil disobedience on other topics. It is an observation I have made of my own actions, and is not done to insight the actions of authorities or activists, and, though I should be, I generally, am not active in any means of changing policies. This inactivity is something I plan to change, as I better my understanding of the issues. Really I ought to be doing these things already, as a disillusioned citizen.

That said, I will explain why the initial statement is more or less the case. Because I think the government is supposed to get the right to rule from the people and act in the interest of the greater good, if I believe a law or policy does not achieve this, I do not believe myself or others to have given consent.

In the war on drugs, the government spends massive amounts of public money to discover, prosecute and incarcerate people who obtain or use illegal drugs. Whether you condemn the use of drugs or not, it should be clear what is contained in any and all of the DEA's policies and schedules. Like many of our favorite legal documents would be unpleasant to read in a casual sense, and I believe this to be no accident.

If any person commits a violation of this subparagraph or of section 849, 859, 860, or 861 of this title after two or more prior convictions for a felony drug offense have become final, such person shall be sentenced to a mandatory term of life imprisonment without release and fined in accordance with the preceding sentence. Any sentence under this subparagraph shall, in the absence of such a prior conviction, impose a term of supervised release of at least 5 years in addition to such term of imprisonment and shall, if there was such a prior conviction, impose a term of supervised release of at least 10 years in addition to such term of imprisonment
http://www.usdoj.gov/dea/pubs/csa/841.htm#a


I think the government has found some sort of reward in convincing the people to be scared of these substances. The drug education programs most elementary school students are subjected to are in my opinion a huge waste of money, and a detriment to the educational institutions. I also think the exaggerations of the effects and nature of the substances is irresponsible and damages their accountability. I remember them saying, more or less, that "if you try marijuana you will want to do cocaine and then heroine, and then you will turn into a horrible monster trying to sell drugs to kids and stealing from your friends and family.." then uses some sort of emotionally packed image as a visual. Now, I may have sensationalized a bit, but actually that was the impression I got from their presentations when I saw them. Also some of the info they provided served more as a how-to than anything, like the substance abuse possibilities of redi-whip type containers, they said that because of the gas used to propel the contents (at the time I believe it was Nitrous oxide or something) a person could get a high feeling, as if floating.

I believe the war on marijuana in particular to have been highly dependent on another shining part of our society, fear mongering and racism. A friend of mine was nice enough to mention to me a quote they heard from a man called the "father of the drug war." Harry J. Anslinger outlined his understanding before a group of people, including some from what was called the Ways and Means Committee, he answered a series of questions which I thought were valuable in characterizing the understanding of marijuana when efforts against it first began. There are parts I believe to be distinctly false, and some which I think are useful, and should be re-evaluatd and hopefully accepted.

MR. MCCORMACK: Is it used by the criminal class?

MR. ANSLINGER: Yes, it is. It is dangerous to the mind and body, and particularly dangerous to the criminal type, because it releases all of the inhibitions.

I have here statements by the foremost expert in the world talking on this subject, and by Dr. Cutter a noted and distinguished medical man in this country.

(The statements referred to are as follows:)

(From the report by Dr. J. Bouquet, Tunis, to the League of Nations)

Does Indian hemp (Cannabis Sativa) in its various forms give rise to drug addiction?

The use of cannabis, whether smoked or ingested in its various form, undoubtedly gives rise to a form of addiction, which has serious social consequences (abandonment of work, propensity to theft and crime, disappearance of reproductive power).

-From the Washington Post, Nov. 23, 1936-
I do not believe marijuana is addictive, short of peoples interest in its effects. The effects of marijuana I do not think encourage violence, in fact aside from the effects of greed in the illegal sales of it, I see little evidence that aside from the monetary aspect of the drug it encourages any ill will between people.
Anslinger says something I believe to be true though,

MR. DINGELL: I am just wondering whether the marihuana addict graduates into a heroin, an opium, or a cocaine user.

MR. ANSLINGER: No, sir; I have not heard of a case of that kind. I think it is an entirely different class. The marihuana addict does not go in that direction.

http://www.druglibrary.org/SCHAFFER/hemp/taxact/anslng1.htm

Based on my understanding (and whatever level of objectivity I have) I do not think the punishments fit the crimes, especially in the case of marijuana. I can understand holding responsible people who sell chemicals which result in the death of the user, but aside from protecting the physical health of the people using the substances, I see few common good type purposes (and would like to shine a little attention on the substances allowed which are likely much more deadly but are too lucrative for the government to get rid of).

One aspect of my feelings on our drug policy is its effect on juveniles. Firstly I would like to clarify, that I do not think incarceration of young persons improves their behavior or is otherwise in their best interest. That said, it saddens me that drug related offenses are grouped in with violent crime, as I think many people who do drugs do not interfere with the wellbeing of others, or pose a threat to society. I will use marijuana throughout this, because it is the fairest example I know... other drugs have greater effect on the person's free will (through levels of awareness and addictive properties). What I see is a large population of people being imprisoned or otherwise prosecuted because of their involvement with drugs. I've been reading from the Bureau of Justice Statistics and found some key pieces interesting (I reference the site first so others can look at it, but also to clarify why my sources are from given years, or to allow congruent research) this is the address http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/pubalp2.htm#cpus.

What I see is that about 15% of the juveniles in the system had their worst offense drug related,
and that in 1994 many, the average duration of punishment for these crimes was longer than that of violent crimes; 21 months for drug offenders versus 17months for violent offenders. http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/dcf/correct.htm#Juveniles

This doesn't jive. I really despise this system, and it scares me to think of what my community would be like if all the people who did drugs were prosecuted. I do not think young people should have criminal records for their lifetime for possession of marijuana (young people for me being not only those under 18, but also up to say 25 when I believe the structure of the brain has stopped its fundamental development, that like other parts I am especially receptive to arguments for/against..) Some of the smartest most compassionate people I have met have also tried or use regularly illegal drugs. I do not believe at this time, that if I were asked to provide information leading to their prosecution that I would.

My non-cooperation is a direct result of the my opinions of the law itself. I look at the laws restricting alcohol, and its role in criminal acts, as a control, and see a serious discrepancy.
In convicted adult offenders, in 1996, nearly 2 million of 5.3 convicted offenders were thought to have been drinking at the time of the offense, that is about 36%.
http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/pub/pdf/ac.pdf Now, as a pseudo-educated individual I have to recognize that there is good reason for people not to admit to use of other substances, and that alcohol is more common, but I think that only changes a small portion of the data.
why do I believe the laws are protecting alcohol and cracking down on other substances? It could be any variety of reasons, cultural/social influences, enforceability , but I believe the paramount issue to be economic. It is harder to profit from marijuana, and we don't manufacture most of the illegal substances brought into the country. (If we could make cocaine in the U.S as easily as we can make alcohol, I wonder if this would be different. Alternately, if marijuana didn't grow so well naturally and is therefore be impossible to control the market on, I wonder if policies would change here.)

Now to answer the question that has likely surfaced in reading my thoughts on drugs.
Have I tried marijuana? no
Do I plan to? no, and I'll tell you why. My goal is to be a surgeon, to be directly responsible for the wellbeing of a patient, and through a combination of my actions, the assistance of other medical professionals and the vast studies of medical sciences to achieve the best result for that individual. I do not want to do anything that puts other people at risk, and on the chance that there is some negative effect in my abilities or situation because of drugs, I choose to avoid them. My specific plan to be a surgeon might not materialize for some reason, but my goal would be the same, to directly assist or positively effect the wellbeing of other individuals.

I've stated my feeling that government is supposed to get the right to rule from the people and act in the interest of the greater good, and because I think our laws regarding marijuana are not, I would not expect myself to assist the government or anybody else in enforcing them. If they were reformed to reflect appropriate caution in the distribution and availability of the drug, I would probably change my position. I wish very much that there could be a comprehensive review of the scientific and statistical information available, as well as social issues regarding marijuana, and that people could be treated fairly, and the drug's criminality be reconsidered by a party which has no vested interest but for the well being of the people here and elsewhere.

Expanding on Science and Skepticism a bit. (oct 16)

Please refer to http://cdn.libsyn.com/skepticsguide/skepticast2006-12-13.mp3

This is a 'podcast' I listen to, actually the only one I listen to so far, and it generally is really entertaining and has speakers and stories carried by some hardcore research. This particular one includes some thoughts on Ahmadinejad, along with fun philosophy and science type questions.


In addition to the discussion of Ahmadinejad, they have speaker Allen Wallace. . if you do listen to either the podcast or speech, which I think you should, be aware that Allen Wallace is a kind of comic relief as this show goes..

He brings the lack of tangibility of thoughts as why we cannot measure the phenomena itself... he seems to pose questions asking whether you can think something without correlating brain activity.

The interviewer asks are brain functions necessary for subjective experience to exist. Wallace says that there are people (in computers) he believes who say you don't need a brain.
the interviewer says that his statement is a non-sequitur..

Any level of consciousness can be attributed to some part of the brain. I don't think Wallace agrees with this, and this means he is in denial of reality. I cite this with his analysis of computers rather than human anatomy.

What may be happening here is like with Ahmadinejad. I think Wallace's definition of science, especially consciousness is different than mine (and probably other ethical at least halfway educated or skeptical people)

Wallace asks that the interviewer prove impossible this non-science. He asks the interviewer "can you envision a scientific experiment, a rigorous mainstream scientific experiment, that actually could in principle refutiate the hypothesis that all possible states of consciousness must have a physical basis for their generation... can you design me an experiment"
Interviewer responds "the short answer is no," "you're asking can you prove that is impossible, and science does not operate that way."

I am not an expert on the workings of the human brain, even anatomically speaking I have more to study (past the names of key structures and some brief descriptions of function).

These types of discussion are a larger issue. It is the ability to bastardize science when considering the realms of politics or religion, especially when using information based in pseudo science, that I find so disturbing. To reiterate my previous point. Like church and state are best separate, I think science, church, and state should be separate.

Science and Translation (oct 15)

I was reading Ahmadinejad's address to the students at Colombia, and there was something he talked about that I wasn't expecting. Like most speeches there were parts where I agree with the speaker, and many where I cannot agree. What startled me though was his thoughts on science.

Like many things there is much I have to learn about Ahmadinejad, but this alone is cause for investigation. I believe his basic definition of science to be different than mine. In my mind science and religion should not be intertwined. Religion often stifles scientific discovery, and no scientific study can be done properly if meeting the needs of a particular religion. Those two are for me like church and state, they might cover the same ideas, but should not be part of one another's authority.

Here are some examples of what he said about science as he defines it. Now, I've chosen to not get into some of the other interesting topics he discusses (like holocaust, palestine, nuclear war and terrorism, his thoughts on terrorism are something I hadn't actually thought of) until some other time.

"In our culture, the word science has been defined as illumination,
In fact, the science means brightness and the real science is a science which rescues the human being from ignorance, to his own benefit. In one of the widely accepted definitions of science, it is stated that it is the light which sheds to the hearts of those who have been selected by the almighty.

Therefore, according to this definition, science is a divine gift and the heart is where it resides. If we accept that science means illumination, then its scope supersedes the experimental sciences and it includes every hidden and disclosed reality.

One of the main harms inflicted against science is to limit it to experimental and physical sciences. This harm occurs even though it extends far beyond this scope. Realities of the world are not limited to physical realities and the materials, just a shadow of supreme reality. And physical creation is just one of the stories of the creation of the world.

Human being is just an example of the creation that is a combination of a material and the spirit. And another important point is the relationship of science and purity of spirit, life, behavior and ethics of the human being. In the teachings of the divine prophets, one reality shall always be attached to science; the reality of purity of spirit and good behavior. Knowledge and wisdom is pure and clear reality.

It is -- science is a light. It is a discovery of reality. And only a pure scholar and researcher, free from wrong ideologies, superstitions , selfishness and material trappings can discover -- discover the reality.
My dear friends and scholars, distinguished participants, science and wisdom can also be misused, a misuse caused by selfishness, corruption, material desires and material interests, as well as individual and group interests.

Material desires place humans against the realities of the world.

Corrupted and dependent human beings resist acceptance of reality. And even if they do accept it, they do not obey it.

There are many scholars who are aware of the realities but do not accept them. Their selfishness does not allow them to accept those realities.

Do those who, in the course of human history, wage wars, not understand the reality that lives, properties, dignity, territories, and the rights of all human beings should be respected, or did they understand it but neither have faith in nor abide by it?

My dear friends, as long as the human heart is not free from hatred, envy, and selfishness, it does not abide by the truth, by the illumination of science and science itself.

Science is the light, and scientists must be pure and pious. If humanity achieves the highest level of physical and spiritual knowledge but its scholars and scientists are not pure, then this knowledge cannot serve the interests of humanity, and several events can ensue.

First, the wrongdoers reveal only a part of the reality, which is to their own benefit, and conceal the rest. As we have witnessed with respect to the scholars of the divine religions in the past, too, unfortunately, today, we see that certain researchers and scientists are still hiding the truth from the people.

Second, science, scientists, and scholars are misused for personal, group, or party interests. So, in today's world, bullying powers are misusing many scholars and scientists in different fields with the purpose of stripping nations of their wealth.

... And they use all opportunities only for their own benefit. For example, they deceive people by using scientific methods and tools. They, in fact, wish to justify their own wrongdoings, though. By creating nonexistent enemies, for example, and an insecure atmosphere, they try to control all in the name of combating insecurity and terrorism.

They even violate individual and social freedoms in their own nations under that pretext. They do not respect the privacy of their own people. They tap telephone calls and try to control their people.

They create an insecure psychological atmosphere in order to justify their warmongering acts in different parts of the world.

As another example, by using precise scientific methods and planning, they begin their onslaught on the domestic cultures of nations, the cultures which are the result of thousands of years of interaction, creativity and artistic activities. ...

Man's search for knowledge and the truth through science is what it guarantees to do in getting close to God.

But science has to combine with the purity of the spirit and of the purity of man's spirit so that scholars can unveil the truth and then use that truth for advancing humanity's cause.

These scholars would be not only people who would guide humanity, but also guide humanity towards a better future.

And it is necessary that big powers should not allow mankind to engage in monopolistic activities and to prevent other nations from achieving that science. Science is a divine gift by God to everyone, and therefore, it must remain pure.

God is aware of all reality. All researchers and scholars are loved by God. So I hope there will be a day where these scholars and scientists will rule the world and God himself will arrive with Moses and Christ and Mohammed to rule the world and to take us toward justice. "

There was more in his speech, and I plan to, as I suggest you do, read it thoroughly.
I cannot judge this man, as I cannot judge anyone, especially seeing that I do not know the culture he comes from, but I know he is idealogical and intelligent. I in many parts of this am concerned by subtle or not so subtle statements pertaining to those issues I chose to forgo earlier.

I watched a bit of news surrounding it, and from what they showed I'd have known nothing of what he said, or understood any part of the event, and that disappoints me. The footage they showed was severely edited down (as to not bore our audience or something similar) and no conclusion about his goal in speaking or our governments relationship to him could have been derived from it.